David Ryan's is one of the few places in Edgartown that stays open year-round, making it a reliable gathering spot for locals and visitors alike. Set on North Water Street in the heart of the village, it works as both a casual restaurant and a proper pub, with a long bar that gets lively in the evenings.
The menu covers standard American pub fare — burgers, fish and chips, chowder — done well enough that people keep coming back. In summer, expect crowds and a wait, especially on weekends. In the off-season, it is a much more relaxed affair and a good place to get a feel for island life when the tourists have gone home.