One of the oldest continuously operating hotels in California, the Murphys Hotel has been putting up travelers since 1856 — back when the town it's named after was a serious economic engine, not a charming backwater. The building is a solid stone structure typical of Gold Rush-era Murphys, built to survive fire in a way that wooden buildings couldn't. Inside, the lobby and bar have been restored without being fussed over: wood, brick, and a certain lived-in quality that distinguishes the real thing from themed approximations.
The restaurant and bar are open to non-guests, which makes the hotel a natural stop on any visit to Main Street. Stop in for a drink even if you're not staying — it's the kind of place that rewards an hour of sitting and looking around. The hotel also runs a modern lodge section for those who want the address without the antique plumbing, but the rooms in the historic building are worth the upgrade.