The Right Slice is a small pie shop in Koloa town that has built a loyal following among both residents and visitors. The menu focuses on sweet and savoury pies made with local ingredients — tropical fruit fillings including guava, lilikoi (passion fruit), and Kauai-grown produce, alongside more familiar flavours done well. The savoury options change seasonally and are worth asking about.
The shop is in a small plantation-era building on Koloa's main street, easy to miss if you're driving fast but exactly the kind of place that makes the town worth stopping in. Order a slice to eat on the small outdoor seating area, or box up a whole pie for a beach picnic. They sell out of popular flavours by mid-afternoon, so go in the morning for the best selection.